On November third, Russian planes dropped bombs on an old school in Zaporizhzhia that was being used to hand out food and as a shelter. When rescue crews and police rushed in to pull people out, the planes came back and bombed it again. At least thirty three people died, including two rescuers and four police officers. Russia's Defense Ministry said it had hit Ukrainian soldiers. Eight days later, Russia's lead negotiator walked out of peace talks in Abu Dhabi and said all the goals we set will be achieved.
Start with the numbers from the United Nations, because nobody can call the United Nations a mouthpiece for Kyiv. The UN's human rights monitors in Ukraine reported that in September alone, at least three hundred twenty eight civilians were killed and two thousand one hundred five were injured. That is eighty five percent more than September of last year. Civilians were hurt in twenty two of Ukraine's regions. Kyiv recorded civilian casualties on twenty two of the thirty days that month, more than in any month since the full invasion began. The UN calls the casualty rate among the deadliest in years.
September was not a bad month by accident. On August thirtieth, Russia's Defense Ministry announced it was preparing massive strikes on Ukraine's energy system. It kept its word. Ukraine's air force counted three thousand one hundred seventy seven Russian attack drones in September, up from two thousand eight hundred fifty in August. On the night of October thirteenth, strikes on Kyiv's three main power stations left about six hundred thousand people in the capital without electricity. The UN's monitors concluded that attacks like these appear to break the basic rules of war. The head of the mission, Danielle Bell, said hitting heat and power as winter comes is bound to cause terrible suffering for ordinary people. The UN also looked back at last winter's strikes on Ukraine's power grid and found the same thing. Russia says it only goes after military targets and the energy that feeds the army. A grandmother in a high rise in Kyiv with no heat in January is not the army.
The list of what has been hit this fall reads like a list of places where families go. On October first, a Russian drone struck a school in Kyiv while children and staff were down in the shelter. The same night, drones hit a bridge carrying the Kyiv metro and the grounds of a nuclear research center. On October sixth and seventh, a missile and drone attack killed twenty two civilians in the town of Pryluky. There were deadly strikes in Kramatorsk on October eighth, in Zaporizhzhia on October tenth, and in Lutsk on October fourteenth. Then came the school in Zaporizhzhia on November third.
That last attack is worth slowing down on, because of how it was done. It is called a double tap. You hit a target, wait for the rescuers to arrive, and hit it again. It is not an accident. It is a choice to kill the people who come to help. President Zelensky called it a vile terrorist strike. Russia's answer was to claim it had killed up to twenty five Ukrainian soldiers there.
There is another kind of killing that has become a Russian specialty in this war, and Ukrainians have a name for it. They call it the human safari.
It happens mostly in the city of Kherson and the towns along the Dnipro River. Russian troops sit on the far bank and fly small drones with cameras across the water. The operators watch the streets through those cameras. When they see a person, they chase that person down and drop explosives on them. A woman walking to a bus stop. A man on a bicycle. A street vendor. Ambulances and rescue crews coming to help. There is video of Russian drones chasing people down the street as they run.
It started in May of twenty twenty four and it has never stopped. By October of last year, the United Nations estimated at least two hundred civilians had been killed this way and more than two thousand wounded. A doctor at a Kherson hospital said they drop explosives from drones like it is a video game. Russian channels on the app Telegram post the videos, with taunts aimed at the people they hit. Many of the drones were bought through fundraisers run by ordinary Russian civilians, and the operators post the footage so donors can see what their money paid for. This year the attacks kept coming. On July first, a drone hit a minibus and killed two people and wounded nine. On August nineteenth, a strike on another minibus reportedly killed three women and a man. Kherson prosecutors have opened about one thousand six hundred fifty criminal cases.
In September of last year, a United Nations commission of inquiry looked at this and found that these drone attacks on civilians along more than three hundred kilometers of the Dnipro amount to crimes against humanity. Specifically, the crime of murder, and the crime of forcing people out of their homes. On one single day this August, a reporter in Kherson counted eleven drone attacks and six civilians wounded. In June, Ukraine's security service charged ten drone operators from Russia's four hundred fourth Motorized Rifle Regiment with war crimes for hunting civilians this way.
Victims have even taken it to court in New York. In August, a group of Ukrainian civilians and families of the dead sued an American company called Ubiquiti. They say its wireless radios became the backbone of the system Russia uses to fly those drones, and that the company could have shut the devices off. Those claims have not been tested in court, and Ubiquiti had not answered them when the case was filed. The lawyer for the victims put it plainly. This case is not about standard warfare, he said. It is about murdering civilians.
Then there are the children. The European Union has confirmed twenty thousand six hundred fifty one cases of Ukrainian children deported to Russia or moved by force within the occupied areas, as of September. As of October twenty eighth, only two thousand seven hundred fifty two children had been brought back. About one point six million Ukrainian children still live in areas under Russian control.
Some of these children have been put up for adoption by Russian families. Lawmakers in the European Parliament have demanded that Russia shut down online catalogues offering Ukrainian children for adoption and foster care. Others are sent through programs to turn them into Russians. Researchers at Yale University's Humanitarian Research Lab have identified at least two hundred ten places across Russia and the occupied areas where Ukrainian children have been held. At least one hundred thirty of them run what the researchers call re education, where children sing the Russian anthem and sit through history lessons taught entirely in Russian. At least thirty nine give military training, including shooting, throwing grenades and flying drones. The researchers found children as young as eight in those programs. In one case, children from the Donetsk region were flown to a military base on aircraft belonging to Putin's own property office for what was called airborne training. The Russian government itself runs more than half of these places. The EU's foreign policy chief, Kaja Kallas, said Russia may be sending some of the kidnapped children to fight against Ukraine.
This is the reason the International Criminal Court issued an arrest warrant for Vladimir Putin in March of twenty twenty three. The warrant charges him with the unlawful deportation of children. It names one other person, Maria Lvova Belova, the woman Putin put in charge of what Russia calls children's rights. Russia calls the deportations evacuations. On November twelfth, the European Parliament voted five hundred thirty six to eight to demand the children be returned, and said their return should never be traded away as part of a land deal or a prisoner swap.
And then there are the homes. Russia has built a legal machine to take the houses and apartments of Ukrainians who fled the occupation. Under Russian law, property can be declared ownerless. Late last year, Putin signed changes that moved the process into federal law and set a deadline of July first of this year for owners to re register their homes with Russian authorities. Once a notice goes up, an owner has thirty days to show up in person.
Think about what that means. To show up in person, a Ukrainian who fled has to travel through Russia and pass what is called filtration, a security screening. Human Rights Watch talked to forty people who tried. Thirty seven were turned away. Russian officials routinely refuse to accept a Ukrainian passport as proof of who you are. Russia's own figures show about four point six million properties registered in the four occupied regions, with five hundred fifty thousand of them lacking papers and at risk of being taken. The UN counted more than thirty eight thousand properties flagged as possibly abandoned.
The July deadline has now passed. In April, Denis Pushilin, the man Moscow installed to run the occupied part of the Donetsk region, said his administration would take the homes of Ukrainians who left Mariupol. In December of last year, the occupation authorities in Mariupol declared one displaced woman's apartment ownerless along with three hundred forty one other properties in a single batch. One Mariupol owner told Human Rights Watch, it's like they announce them ownerless while still admitting they have owners.
Who gets those homes? Russian passport holders. People on housing waiting lists. Teachers, doctors and local officials brought in to run the occupation.
Mariupol shows where this leads. Russia flattened much of that city in twenty twenty two. Now it is building new apartment blocks there, sixty four buildings at last count. The city council in exile says three out of four buyers of the new homes are Russians, most of them from Moscow, drawn in with two percent mortgages, the warm weather and the sea. Meanwhile, about eighteen thousand Ukrainians from Mariupol whose homes were destroyed are still without a place of their own. Only about four thousand five hundred have been approved for replacement housing. A Russian business paper reported in March that Moscow plans to move almost one hundred fourteen thousand of its citizens into the occupied territories by twenty forty five. Mariupol's exiled officials have a word for it. Replacement.
While all of that goes on, Putin keeps sending people to peace talks. Look at the record of what those talks have produced.
In the spring of twenty twenty two, Russian and Ukrainian delegations met in Istanbul and drafted a possible peace deal. Moscow said it would cut back fighting near Kyiv. Within days, the world saw what Russian troops had done in Bucha, and Russia's foreign minister rejected Ukraine's proposal as unacceptable.
In May of last year, the two sides met in Istanbul again, the first direct talks in three years. They agreed to swap one thousand prisoners each. Two more rounds followed in June and July and produced nothing but paperwork. In August, the President met Putin in Alaska. No ceasefire. No agreement. In December, Putin met the President's envoys, Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, in Moscow. The Kremlin called the meeting constructive and said much work remained.
This year there were talks in Abu Dhabi in January and February, which produced a swap of one hundred fifty seven prisoners each, and a round in Geneva in February that went nowhere. Then the Iran war started and the talks went quiet for most of the year.
Last week they started again. On November tenth and eleventh, American, Russian and Ukrainian negotiators met in Abu Dhabi. The meeting lasted about four hours. The sides agreed in principle to another prisoner swap. That was it. No ceasefire. Strikes went on during the talks. The Council on Foreign Relations summed it up in its headline. Abu Dhabi advanced diplomacy, not peace.
Every round looks the same. Russia agrees to swap prisoners, takes its photos, and keeps fighting. The prisoner swaps matter to the families who get their sons back. But they cost Putin nothing, and they let him tell Washington he is negotiating in good faith.
Then on November twelfth, Witkoff and Kushner sat down with Putin at the Kremlin. According to the New York Times, the Russians handed them a paper. It demands that NATO pull its troops out of its eastern members, including Poland and the Baltic states, back to where things stood in nineteen ninety seven, before those countries joined. It demands no more new members. It demands a ban on any military activity by the West in Ukraine, Eastern Europe, the South Caucasus and Central Asia. It demands that France and Britain stop protecting their European allies with their nuclear weapons. It demands a complete end to Western weapons for Ukraine. And it says Ukraine could join the European Union only if it stays out of the EU's common defense.
If that sounds familiar, it should. On December seventeenth, twenty twenty one, Russia published two draft treaties for America and NATO with nearly the same demands, including pulling NATO forces back to the lines of nineteen ninety seven. The West said no to the core of it. On February twenty fourth, twenty twenty two, Russia invaded. Kaja Kallas made exactly that point on Sunday. In twenty twenty one, she said, Russia gave a list of demands as a pretext for war, and now they are presenting the same demands and adding to them, as a pretext for keeping the war going.
On top of that list, Moscow still demands that Ukraine pull its army out of all of the Donbas, including the parts Russia has never been able to take. Russian officials have also said there should be no ceasefire at all until talks on Europe's security are finished. Liana Fix of the Council on Foreign Relations explained why that suits Putin. Russia believes it has the upper hand in its air and missile campaign this winter. A ceasefire would take that away. Dragging the talks into the much bigger question of Europe's security buys months, and lets Moscow blame Europe and Ukraine for the delay when Washington asks why nothing is moving.
How has the American side answered? According to the Times, Witkoff and Kushner told the Russians that circumstances have changed since December twenty twenty one. From Moscow, the two envoys were due to fly on to Dublin to meet Zelensky. Max Boot of the Council on Foreign Relations argued that the talks are a waste of time unless Washington puts more pressure on Russia and gives Ukraine more help. Kushner told reporters the United States believes Russia is ready for peace under the right conditions. He also told the Europeans that if they want a seat at the table, they should pick one person to speak for all of them. The American envoys have said future talks may include European representatives. The Kremlin has not agreed. For almost two years, Europe, which now gives Ukraine more help than anyone, was kept out of the room. Zelensky said the American team also wanted to talk about a whole new security setup for Europe. He called that a Russian idea, meant to redraw who holds power in Europe, and said it should only come up after a ceasefire and an end to the war.
And then, according to President Zelensky, the American negotiators floated something new. Zelensky said on Friday that the Americans asked a question for the first time. What if Ukraine joins NATO, they asked. Would Ukraine then pull out of the Donbas? In other words, give Russia land it has not won, in exchange for a NATO membership Putin has spent his whole career fighting. Zelensky said Ukraine will not give up territory, but that if he got a full security package with real guarantees from NATO and the European Union, he would put it to a public vote, because he has no right to make that decision alone. He also said, we need specifics, and we do not have them yet.
Here is the problem with all of it. The land in question belongs to Ukraine. It is not America's to trade, and it is not Russia's to demand. Putin's own list says Ukraine can never be protected by NATO, never get Western weapons, and never defend itself as part of Europe. No American envoy can promise Ukraine NATO membership, because every NATO country has to agree, and Putin has made clear he would treat it as a reason to keep fighting. A deal that hands over the Donbas first and promises protection later asks Ukraine to trust Moscow one more time.
Ukraine has trusted Moscow before. In nineteen ninety four, under the Budapest Memorandum, Ukraine gave up the nuclear weapons left on its soil after the Soviet Union fell. In return, Russia, America and Britain promised to respect Ukraine's borders and never use force against it. Russia broke that promise in twenty fourteen when it took Crimea, and again in twenty twenty two.
And the lies have not stopped. In the weeks before the invasion, the Kremlin called American warnings about an attack hysteria and insisted it had no plans to invade. It still calls the war a special military operation. It calls the children it took evacuees. It calls a double tap strike on a school full of people a hit on soldiers. It says it does not target civilians while the United Nations counts the dead. When the chief negotiator says all of Russia's goals will be achieved, that is the one statement worth believing.
Now look at what this war has cost the country Putin claims to be protecting.
In May, the head of Britain's signals intelligence agency, Anne Keast Butler of GCHQ, said nearly five hundred thousand Russian soldiers have been killed since twenty twenty two. Half a million dead. A former head of Britain's top defense think tank said the real number might well be higher. The Russian independent outlet Mediazona, working with the BBC, has confirmed two hundred eighty six thousand Russian soldiers killed by name, from obituaries, grave sites and social media posts, as of November sixth. That count only includes the ones they can prove, and it is still growing. Ukraine's military says Russia's killed and wounded together passed one point six million this month. Secretary Rubio has said Russia loses roughly five soldiers for every one Ukraine loses.
What did all of that buy? Russia holds about one fifth of Ukraine, most of it taken in the first weeks of the full invasion or back in twenty fourteen. Since then, the front has barely moved. This spring, the Institute for the Study of War said Russia's gains were approaching net zero. In April, Russia actually lost one hundred sixteen square kilometers, its first net loss of ground in twenty months. Russia did take the city of Pokrovsk late last year, after more than a year of fighting. One city, for a cost no major power has paid since the Second World War.
The economy is paying too. Russia's economy grew just six tenths of one percent in the first half of this year, according to the government's own statistics. That is close to standing still. The government is now expecting a record budget deficit for this year of about eight point six trillion rubles, around four percent of the whole economy, far above its own forecast. Russia has had to dip into its rainy day fund to cover the gap.
Where does the money go? Next year's budget raises defense spending by twenty seven percent, to more than one third of everything the Russian government spends. A record thirty five percent of next year's spending is classified, hidden even from the Russian parliament. To pay for it, Russia raised its main sales tax, the VAT, from twenty to twenty two percent at the start of this year. Its central bank has held its main interest rate at fourteen percent, and prices were still rising about six percent a year in September. Oil and gas money, the backbone of Russia's budget, is expected to fall again next year.
Ordinary Russians feel it. Their savings buy less. Loans for a car or a home cost a fortune at fourteen percent. Hundreds of thousands of their sons, husbands and fathers are dead or wounded. Many of the men who died came from poor regions far from Moscow, recruited with huge signing bonuses. In the Khanty Mansi region, a man who signs up can now get about four point one million rubles, more than forty thousand euros, the biggest single payment in the country. Regions keep raising the money because fewer men are taking it. About two hundred thousand Russians signed army contracts in the first half of this year, down from more than two hundred ten thousand a year earlier. In the first three months of this year, the number of new soldiers getting the federal bonus was the lowest in three years. Some regions now pay recruiters a bounty for every man they bring in.
Russians who speak up pay a price too. Alexei Navalny, the opposition leader, was poisoned with the nerve agent Novichok in twenty twenty, survived, came home, and was thrown in prison. He died in an Arctic prison camp in February of twenty twenty four. Thousands of Russians have been arrested for speaking out against the war. Hundreds of thousands of young men left the country after Putin ordered a call up of reservists in twenty twenty two.
And the man who sent all those soldiers is hiding.
In May, the Financial Times reported that the Kremlin had sharply tightened security around Putin. Fear of a coup or an assassination, especially by drone, grew this spring, according to people close to European intelligence. Putin has been spending more time in underground bunkers, including in the Krasnodar region, sometimes working from there for weeks at a time, while state television plays old footage to make things look normal. He and his family stopped going to their homes outside Moscow and at Valdai. The cooks, photographers and bodyguards around him are banned from riding public transport and from carrying mobile phones or anything that connects to the internet. Their own homes are under surveillance. Some of the internet shutdowns in Moscow have been tied to protecting him from drones. Putin made far fewer public trips this year than the seventeen or more he made last year.
What is he afraid of? Ukraine's drone attack called Operation Spiderweb, which hit Russian airfields as far away as the Arctic Circle, is still a shock inside the Kremlin. The American capture of Venezuela's Nicolas Maduro in January added to the fear. A Russian general, Fanil Sarvarov, was killed in Moscow, and afterward security chiefs blamed each other. Putin ordered his own protection service to guard ten top generals.
He also has reason to fear his own side. In June of twenty twenty three, Yevgeny Prigozhin and his Wagner mercenaries seized a Russian city and marched toward Moscow before turning back. Two months later Prigozhin was dead in a plane crash. Putin's approval rating has fallen to its lowest point since the fall of twenty twenty two, according to both state backed and independent pollsters in Russia.
And then there are the body doubles. Rumors have followed Putin for years that he uses look alikes for some public appearances. Some exiled Russians say there are six or seven. A Japanese television network ran an analysis in twenty twenty three claiming more than one version of Putin had appeared in public. The Kremlin's spokesman called the idea absurd. Putin himself said in a twenty twenty interview that he had been offered doubles years earlier for security reasons and turned them down. Nobody has proved it either way. That a story like that sticks to him at all tells you how he governs. He trusts almost nobody, he hears bad news from almost nobody, and he is seen less and less.
He cannot travel freely either. Because of the war crimes warrant over the children, he risks arrest in more than one hundred twenty countries that belong to the International Criminal Court. He has tested that only once, in twenty twenty four, when he visited Mongolia, a member country, and was not arrested. Mostly he stays where he is safe. He turned seventy four last month.
The war has come home to Russia in other ways. Ukraine's drone forces reported eighty two attacks on energy sites in Russia and the occupied areas in a single stretch this fall. Russian refineries, fuel depots and power plants burn on a regular basis now, far from the front line.
On Thursday, he will be in Shenzhen, China, sitting down with Xi Jinping and the President in the first meeting ever between the leaders of the three countries. American officials say they do not expect an agreement to come out of it, and that the President and Putin will not hold a separate meeting while they are there.
Here is the record. Putin's forces bombed a shelter, waited for the rescuers, and bombed it again. They hunt people in Kherson with drones for sport. They have taken more than twenty thousand children and the homes of Ukrainians who fled, and they are moving Russians into those homes. He sends negotiators to every round of talks and brings back the same demands he made before he invaded. Half a million of his own soldiers are dead, his economy is barely growing, his people are paying more for less, and he spends his days underground, afraid of his own generals and of drones in the sky. All of that, for land he still has not managed to take. Every dollar of pressure on Moscow, and every weapon in Ukraine's hands, brings the day closer when Putin has to stop. Anything handed to him at the table just gives him a reason to keep going.
Now Everyone knows.
AND THATS IT.
That's Everyone knows. The hard truth, the stuff nobody else will say, and the thing that keeps you going.
I'm Brian Bullock of Starborne Studios. Find me on X at Everyoneknows1. If this hits you, share it with someone who needs to hear it. Subscribe. Leave a review. Come find us at brianbullockwriter.com.
Because Everyone knows.
Your Silence is your Consent.